 | Home > Maintenance & Modifications > Auto Conversion |
 
|
|
|
| steveww Member Since: 05 Jan 2022 Location: Uppingham Posts: 539   
|
I guess you did not a good experience with them?
|
||
20th Oct 2022 8:15pm |
|
| MarkBrown Member Since: 03 Oct 2022 Location: Mid Wales Posts: 327 
|
I have a zf 4speed ( which is really like a 5 speed, as when it locks up in 4th gear, the revs drop around 200rpm). It's not as smooth as my other more modern mercedes automatic cars, which are 5 speed ( and are now considered old ) but in my opinion its much better than changing gear with a clutch.
Driven softly it is very smooth. My advice would be to get a drive in a discovery 2 as that's where the gearbox comes from and feels much the same, although it's computer controlled. My zf4 is a rebuilt hydraulic type, therefore has no electronic control, which works well behind the mercedes engine in my 110. Overall it drives just as well as a the discovery 2 V8 which donated the transmission, but goes better! I think what has to be considered when comparing features of modern cars is that most of us don't have the skill or oppertunity to exploit the full benefits of their technically superior engineering anyway. I'm not sure there's anything wrong with the 5 speed in my old merc, so why do I need a 7, 8, 9 or 10 speed? How would I even know if it's better? |
||
|
31st Oct 2022 9:20am |
|
| diesel_jim Member Since: 13 Oct 2008 Location: hiding Posts: 6040 
|
Mark, don't know the cost but this: https://www.defender2.net/forum/topic85488.html
|
||
|
6th Nov 2022 9:38pm |
|
| SteveG Member Since: 29 Nov 2011 Location: Norfolk Posts: 656 
|
The majority of the reasons for car manufacturers going above 6 speed autos is fuel economy. Beyond a good 6 speed auto like the ZF, there really is no driving reward for adding extra cogs. The fuel economy gains at average road speeds are worthwhile, hence the gradual increase. |
||
|
7th Nov 2022 10:56am |
|
| LR Sam Member Since: 08 Nov 2012 Location: Yorkshire Posts: 226 
|
Hi Walfy,
Agreed with comments above. The ZF4 is a good way of getting an automatic Defender. It isn't like a new style auto but you will be happy if you go for it. It is also ultra reliable from my experience having fitted quite a few. 6 speed from JE - the only one I drove didn't work well with a puma engine, it ended up changing gear too often so you never really got to use the torque of the engine. This must have been 5 years ago or so, they might well have improved it. If you are keeping standard LR engine, I would be tempted to go ZF4 speed from ashcroft as it has been tested/fitted by so many people. |
||
|
7th Nov 2022 12:01pm |
|
| Andy McPandy Member Since: 04 Oct 2019 Location: Dorset Posts: 11 
|
I have the JE autobox and I have found it excellent. Agreed it's an expensive piece of kit but it works really well.
|
||
|
1st Dec 2022 6:54pm |
|
| drakes Member Since: 09 Oct 2009 Location: Hexham Posts: 111 
|
I've had an Ashcroft 4 speed auto in my TD5 90 for the last 15 years and yes it's not as refined as a modern electronic auto but we are talking about a Defender which is not exactly up to modern refinement standards anyway. I've done about 70k since the conversion and have never regretted it and would not go back to manual again
|
||
|
1st Dec 2022 7:23pm |
|
| walfy Member Since: 29 Aug 2007 Location: Frome Posts: 2642 
|
Just a quick update, I'm ever hopeful my 110 sells and this proves to be a pointless task for me but if it doesn't sell I'll need to move fast as my company year end loms quickly and I need to spend some money or give a load to the robber, sorry HMRC man.
Anyway, I've asked a fellow forumer to look at his JE version, I'll then need to find someone close to me with an Ashcroft version to look at or it's a long drive to see them. I mailed a couple of companys about doing the conversion as well. 1 responded but they were stacked out and wouldn't commit, another new kid on the block with a flashy youtube channel doing Defender builds haven't even responded. So they are now out of the picture even if they do respond now. A bit late after a month of me sending an enquiry. So even if mine does sell hopefully any info I post will be of use to someone in the future 110 D250 SE HT 110 USW SOLD RRE HSE Dynamic Gone, wife killed it VOLVO XC60 R Dynamic with some toys Polaris RZR 900XP SOLD |
||
|
5th Dec 2022 4:55pm |
|
|
|
| All times are GMT + 1 Hour |
< Previous Topic | Next Topic > |
Posting Rules
|
Site Copyright © 2006-2024 Futuranet Ltd & Martin Lewis
