 | Home > Puma (Tdci) > Another output shaft failure... |
 
|
|
|
| helmutk Member Since: 12 Dec 2011 Location: Graz Posts: 15   
|
One can only hope...
In the meantime I will try to get extra-sensitive for driveline-backlash. Oh, and not to get caught in the middle of nowhere at 120000 km   |
||
4th Aug 2016 9:50pm |
|
| pannawonica Member Since: 21 Nov 2010 Location: Clackline Western Australia Posts: 568 
|
[quote="helmutk"][quote="Fatboy Slim"]Hate to say it, but I've found greasing them a waste of time. Unless you can keep greasing it the grease just dries out and becomes a rusty grinding paste on the splines.[/quote]
^^This! MY2011 2.4 1st one replaced after 41000km under warranty (3rd year). Assembled dry, replace was greased. 2nd one failed after further 45000km/3 years.  Seems greasing is not worth the effort.
Now I fitted the Ashcroft-kit. Let's see how long this will last...[/quote] I think Blackwolf was on too it, when he suggested that it was maybe not just related too lubrication! That there was an alignment issue also, the accuracy of the machining. Remains too be seen how the Ashcroft kit copes with this. Personally Im hoping that theirs is the solution!   |
||
|
5th Aug 2016 3:07am |
|
| helmutk Member Since: 12 Dec 2011 Location: Graz Posts: 15
|
I don't think this one-time greasing is sufficient. As written, (Almost) no grease remained in the spline, mine was as good as dry with lots of red dust in the housing.
When I had BMW K75 (Motorcycle) back in the day I had to grease the drive shaft to propel drive (?) every other year or so. Not mentioned in the manual, so the first spline got carious by tribocorrosion fast. |
||
|
5th Aug 2016 7:11am |
|
| mega Member Since: 23 Oct 2010 Location: notts Posts: 33  
|
could it be down to heat treatment issues. It would be nice to get a load of used and some new ones for hardness testing.
 |
||
|
5th Aug 2016 5:09pm |
|
| Fifth Horseman Member Since: 08 Mar 2011 Location: Lanarkshire Posts: 322  
|
I did wonder about alignment when this issue surfaced in 2012 http://www.defender2.net/forum/topic11955-75.html it would certainly explain the variability in shaft life between vehicles. My first TDCi defender had no problems at around 80K mils when I sold it (bad move), my current Defender destroyed the shaft let year, about a year into ownership http://www.defender2.net/forum/topic38519.html Its now giving symptoms of imminent demise again (but at least managed to get me back from work) some 20K miles later |
||
|
31st Aug 2016 9:37pm |
|
| AlanH Member Since: 15 Mar 2010 Location: WA Posts: 242
|
I've just had my shaft renewed with an OE job but had a rubber boot fitted over the critical area packed with grease. Even the mechanic who did the job doesn't know if it'll be a lasting solution but as long as it does the job for the next couple of months until I've got shot of the thing, I don't care.
I would have had the Ashcroft part fitted but I had plans to go away on a long trip to some reasonably remote country and didn't want to wait for one to be shipped to Oz and the wait time was an unknown at that stage . Then a hernia had to be fixed before I went so those travel plans were scuppered...... The Cook still loves Defenders and has threatened not to cook again.....but I'm afraid for me this one is the worst out of the 3 we've had due mostly to Ford cost cutting. The darkside is calling once again .......... 
AlanH. PS. The shaft removed showed a lot of wear ( and red rust) on the drive side of the splines so it would have gone sometime in the future. |
||
|
1st Sep 2016 9:05am |
|
| shaggydog Member Since: 12 Aug 2012 Location: Kent Posts: 3346 
|
Why not just get a pre TDCI one?
No need to leave the fold  Running Restoration Thread http://www.defender2.net/forum/post323197.html#323197
Self confessed mileage hunter |
||
|
1st Sep 2016 1:04pm |
|
| Fatboy Slim Member Since: 04 Feb 2008 Location: Bridgend Posts: 1006 
|
You were lucky to get that much out of it. You can see what I mean now...... |
||
|
1st Sep 2016 7:22pm |
|
| AlanH Member Since: 15 Mar 2010 Location: WA Posts: 242
|
No more Defenders for me Shaggy. I've had 1 of each now (300Tdi, Td5, 2.4 Puma) and that's quite enough for anyone wanting to remain sane.
Problem is what to replace it with? I did have a 120 series Prado for over 4 years some time back and must say it was very reliable, but oh so easy to scratch and dent that plastic. Plus it sucked juice much faster than the Deafener. Maybe younger bro will flog me his RRS Autobio when the warranty runs out........ won't be cheap but will be in top condition.
AlanH. |
||
|
2nd Sep 2016 9:34am |
|
| tuesdayfox Member Since: 23 Jun 2013 Location: Sydney,OZ Posts: 129 
|
I agree. I am not a mechanic but when I pull mine apart, the output shaft was almost 100%. Even without much grease. Also after a clutch replacement, the gearbox feels so much better with reduced hbacklash. |
||
|
5th Sep 2016 11:27am |
|
| AWOL Member Since: 31 Oct 2013 Location: UK Posts: 222 |
Mine has joined at 25k... 3 days prior to it's 3rd birthday. TC light has flashed/kicked in unexpectedly maybe 2-3 times in past few months on pull away: not sure if linked but, if so, a possible leading indicator of failure? |
||
|
5th Mar 2017 10:23am |
|
| defender9 Member Since: 12 Mar 2016 Location: Fylde Coast Posts: 1613 
|
Without reading all the posts on this problem it would be interesting to see if it became more prevalent after a certain point in time. I had my 07 Puma 110 for 8 years with no problems. I know there would be numerous variable such as how well a vehicle has been serviced, the way it was driven, whether it was constantly hauling heavy loads however when I was working as a Quality Manager and investigating customer complaints, the valid complaints were invariably due to a change which had been made to the manufacturing process. Looking back at some other common Defender problems TD5 , 300tdi they seem to have been to do with poor design in the first instance and this could be the issue with the output shaft or as I mentioned initially did something change sometime during the production years to give rise to this problem?
|
||
|
5th Mar 2017 12:42pm |
|
| Caterham Member Since: 06 Nov 2008 Location: Birmingham Posts: 6264 
|
Has anyone had significant warnings prior failure or do they just go as my last one did.
In the space of 200 miles today mine seems to have got a shed load of play in the drive train and I suspect the adapter shaft is just about to go  |
||
|
16th Mar 2017 7:49pm |
|
| Caterham Member Since: 06 Nov 2008 Location: Birmingham Posts: 6264
|
It's fubarred and I'm stranded!
|
||
|
16th Mar 2017 8:43pm |
|
|
|
| All times are GMT + 1 Hour |
< Previous Topic | Next Topic > |
Posting Rules
|
Site Copyright © 2006-2024 Futuranet Ltd & Martin Lewis
